5 things to know when buying chocolate
Choosing a chocolate bar involves more than just taste — how it is made matters, too. Behind popular brands are concerns about chocolate production, including environmental damage and human rights issues. Here’s what to know before buying chocolate.

When it comes to buying chocolate with an eye toward sustainability or ethics, things can get complicated. While you might be drawn to your favorite childhood treat, if it’s a mass-produced product from a prominent brand, like a Snickers or a KitKat, the realities of how it’s made may dim the glow of nostalgia. Chocolate production has some unsavory practices, including environmental and human rights problems, and that’s especially true of the bigger brands that prioritize profits over much else.
As Lela Nargi has reported for FoodPrint, and as we covered in episode 22 of our podcast, “What You’re Eating,” cocoa is among a handful of commodity crops grown in the Global South by small, impoverished (read: powerless) farmers in a system that’s rife with exploitation of both workers and the earth. The multinational food and drink corporations that buy these crops support a system plagued by a multiplicity of ills, including child and/or forced labor, lack of living wages, deforestation and sexual assault.

Despite efforts to correct the decades-long misbehaviors of the chocolate industry, most corporate commitments have been largely unrealized and many of the issues have actually gotten worse in the time during which companies were supposed to have been improving them. A 2020 study found that child slavery and dangerous working conditions in West African cocoa production have increased in the two decades since large corporations like Mars, Hershey and Nestlé promised to eliminate them by signing a global cocoa-chocolate sector accord known as the Harkin-Engels protocol. In 2021, these corporations were brought to court by former child cocoa farmworkers who accused the companies of encouraging child slavery through supplying training, fertilizer, tools and other support to the cocoa farms. The case was eventually dismissed in the Supreme Court, because the court was unwilling to find the U.S. companies culpable for something happening in supply chains that are hidden from view in other countries.
At the same time, chocolate also plays a role in harming the planet: Its production fuels more than 60 percent of agricultural deforestation in the countries where cocoa is a chief export. According to the World Wildlife Foundation (WWF), in an article introducing their early 2026 report on the commodity crop, “cocoa cultivation, long associated with deforestation in West Africa, is now driving a dangerous new front of forest loss in some of the world’s most critical tropical ecosystems.” And because climate change is rendering traditional cocoa-production areas increasingly inhospitable to the crop, more and more of that production is being moved into forests. As WWF has said, “The message is clear: without an urgent transformation of the cocoa sector, the world will keep losing irreplaceable forests just as climate impacts accelerate and global cocoa demand continues to rise.”
When labels aren’t enough
Given all this, buying “ethical” chocolate is a challenge. Several years ago we spoke to labor expert Anna Canning (then the campaigns manager for an organization called Fair World Project). She advised supporting the companies with good practices, rather than looking for the right certification. “Instead of a certified bar from a company who’s also getting sued by formerly enslaved former child laborers, look to invest in the long-term — supporting companies working to build a different kind of supply chain and industry,” she told FoodPrint in an interview.
This can be harder than it sounds, thanks to certain types of package labeling and marketing aimed at obfuscating the harsher realities.
“Overall, as we think about what ethical labels mean, it’s time for a bit of a paradigm shift,” she says. “So much of ethical marketing has to date focused on making the person buying the product the hero. The rush of ‘guilt-free this’ or ‘slave-free that’ or the really common rhetoric of ‘with each purchase, you help lift a person out of poverty.’ I think that it’s really high time for that to change.” That change, she suggests, includes no longer letting chocolate producers off the hook for these unsavory practices.
But not to be discouraged — it is possible to source chocolate that aligns more closely with your values. Here are five tips to keep in mind.
Go for the good stuff
The first step is getting away from the big producers, like Nestlé, Mars and Hershey. This can be tricky since these large corporations own many brands, and some familiar candies may not be made by the producer you’d assume. Just one surprising example: Nestlé Crunch bars aren’t made by Nestlé at all. (They are now made by Ferrero, which acquired U.S. rights to all of Nestlé’s chocolate and confectionery brands in 2018.) Similarly, Hershey’s makes KitKats — which, confusingly, are still made by Nestlé in the UK and globally — plus the tastealike toffee bars Skor and Heath, and the Reese’s Peanut Butter line. Then there’s Mars, which produces brands like Snickers and M&Ms.
This kind of corporate consolidation and cross-pollination begets more than confusion: As disappointed consumers have noted, when huge chocolate producers buy up smaller candy brands, they often change the formulations to make them cheaper and, frankly, worse.
Instead, seek out smaller, independent brands offering organic, sustainable options; recycled packaging; and detailed information on the packaging and company’s website about the brand’s production methods, standards and commitments. Shopping at a specialty grocery store or health food store may provide a more varied selection; also look for a local chocolate producer.
Look for labels that highlight environmental responsibility
Unfortunately, there is no one-size-fits-all label incorporating environmental and social concerns for chocolate. When it comes to environmental sustainability, the USDA Organic label is a good place to start. “The USDA Organic [label] means that it was grown without chemical inputs that are harmful to the people who grow the ingredients and the planet we all share,” says Canning. Buying organic chocolate ensures that the cocoa, dairy, sugar and other ingredients were produced without chemical fertilizers or harmful pesticides. And because organic cocoa beans are primarily grown in Central and South America, buying organic chocolate sidesteps many of the labor issues associated with cocoa grown in West Africa.
“Fair trade” certifications may not be as trustworthy as they seem
As noted, big chocolate producers are adept at using language that hints at ethical practices in the supply chain but doesn’t necessarily portray the realities; in fact, these hollow promises often bely darker truths. That can make it challenging for consumers to sort out what’s what.
As Beyond Good’s founder and CEO Tim McCollum told us in our podcast episode on vanilla and chocolate, the main issue is poverty. McCollum explains that cocoa is a cash crop — thus the money is untraceable — and most cocoa farmers have just one to two acres; it’s subsistence living. He continues, “… there’s no ability for the farmer to earn, forget about a living wage, like a thriving wage where they can actually grow and develop and move forward. And so you have 3 million cocoa farmers living in near permanent poverty, and there’s no traceability. … Those two things together, very deep poverty and zero traceability, that kind of creates this tinderbox for all this other bad stuff to happen, whether it’s deforestation or forced labor.”
In traditional supply chains, the cocoa pod goes from the farmers to collector, exporter, shipper and then chocolate producer, with money being exchanged each step of the way. The farmers tend to receive the smallest portion of this; a 2020 report found that farmers only earn 6.6 percent of the retail price of a chocolate bar. When families can’t earn enough to support themselves, they are more inclined to put their children to work, perpetuating problems including limited education access, illiteracy rates and other issues within the communities.
Looking at labels, and understanding what they really signify, is one way to decipher a chocolate brand’s commitments to price and working condition standards. While Rainforest Alliance is the most widely used certification when it comes to chocolate, Canning points out that its standards and enforcement are both lacking.
Of the various fair trade organizations, two are prevalent in the U.S.: Fairtrade America, a branch of Fairtrade International, and Fair Trade USA. As if the names of the organizations aren’t already confusingly similar, the certifications they offer — the Fairtrade Mark and Fair Trade Certified, respectively — even have similar logos. Both ensure farmers are given a floor price for commodities, set minimum standards for working conditions and ban child labor. They also come with environmental stipulations, though these are less comprehensive than other, more environmentally focused labels (such as Certified Organic). There are differences between the two labels, mostly having to do with the structure of the fair trade system in question, but for a consumer seeking out more ethical chocolate, both of these labels are a good launching point. Their auditing systems mean that the presence of either one is likely a step up from products that make claims about being fair trade but that don’t have any certification.
Beyond labels, Canning suggests consumers “do a little research to see who owns the chocolate brand you’re buying.” Unlike large corporations, many of the smaller brands that are committed to a fair, sustainable chocolate industry have made their supply chains public. See below for suggested brands.
When buying the good stuff, expect to pay more for it
It’s likely you will notice higher prices when shopping for brands that have committed to boosting wages for farmers or eco-friendly cultivation. A Beyond Good bar, for instance, costs about three times more than a standard KitKat bar. In many cases, it’s the detrimental environmental practices and enslaved labor of chocolate production, along with the low prices farmers receive, that keep that cheap chocolate cheap, while also resulting in big profits for the corporations.
While there is a large divide between chocolate that is produced with integrity and the products pushed out by the larger corporations, there is also a lot of gray area, with some companies doing some things better, while others seem to make commitments for optics alone. What does a truly fair, sustainable chocolate industry look like?
To begin with, cocoa farmers must be paid a living income. Some brands are working directly with farmers to do just that. “We gave the farmers a contract that said, ‘As long as you meet our quality specifications, we will buy every cocoa bean you bring to us,’” McCollum told Nargi in an interview about how Beyond Good has cut the middlemen from their supply chain to increase prices and improve quality of life for their farmers, while also producing a better quality chocolate bar. According to McCollum, the farmers dry and ferment the beans before selling them directly to the small company, where they are further processed in a Madagascar factory not far from where they are grown. “Along with the higher price for [growing heirloom] beans, the contract gave farmers incentives to farm better and figure out how to get more yield from their land; it turns them into cocoa entrepreneurs.”
Other brands pushing for change include Massachusetts-based Taza, Seattle’s Theo and Switzerland’s Alter Eco. Chocolate cooperatives, such as Divine Chocolate and Equal Exchange, provide higher wages for their farmer-owners, and the model also gives the producers involved a stronger voice in the chocolate industry. For more options, Slave Free Chocolate maintains a list of brands that use only ethically sourced cocoa (and highlights those that didn’t make the cut) and Green America’s annual Chocolate Scorecard ranks nationally available brands on both environmental and social dimensions.
Educate yourself — and then spread the word
To get a clearer sense of what consumers can do, we asked Allie Brudney, a senior staff attorney at Corporate Accountability Lab, an organization working to protect people and the planet from corporate abuse. Although Brudney is skeptical of most certification schemes and believes strong enforcement and regulation are what’s needed most, she makes clear that money talks. As she notes on our podcast: “We’re always looking to see how we can incentivize companies to clean up their supply chains. I think that access to the U.S. market or limiting that access is a really big incentive. Companies want access to the United States because it’s a huge market. We sell and buy so many goods of every type that blocking that access can be a real push for companies to clean up their supply chains.”
As consumers, choosing where to spend our money gives us more agency than we might imagine. So does the ability to use our collective voice.
As Brudney says, “I think consumers can also be talking to their retailers and chocolate companies and saying, ‘I want to know what you’re doing right now to eliminate hazardous child labor and forced labor.’”
Key takeaways
- Mass-produced chocolate from prominent global brands is plagued with a host of human rights and environmental problems.
- When shopping for better chocolate, there is no one-size-fits-all label that addresses both environmental and social concerns.
- If prioritizing environmental responsibility, seek out the USDA Organic label.
- If you’re concerned about social issues such as living wages, forced labor or worker safety, educate yourself on the basics of fair trade labels, noting that different labels carry different commitments.
- Generally speaking, when looking for chocolate that’s made more responsibly and sustainably, skip the major manufacturers. Instead, seek out smaller brands using better practices (though note that these often come with a higher price tag, too).
