Your guide to buying and cooking a heritage turkey for Thanksgiving

by Jerusha Klemperer

Published: 11/06/18, Last updated: 11/07/23

If you eat turkey and are interested lowering your Thanksgiving foodprint — having a meal that is better for people, animals and the environment — consider getting a heritage bird. “Heritage,” similarly to “heirloom,” refers to breeds that have remained unchanged over many generations — turkeys prized for their flavor and not necessarily their size. They’re completely different from Butterball and other commercially raised turkey breeds, which have been bred to produce the maximum amount of breast meat in as short a time as possible.

Because they are genetically similar to wild turkeys and often live on smaller farms that use more humane practices, heritage turkeys tend to live better lives than those raised in the confinement of concentrated animal feeding operations (or CAFOs), which also have a detrimental environmental impact. Industrial operations often feel the need to add salt or flavor enhancements to their final product; heritage breeds, in addition to having a much smaller foodprint, also taste better.

Animal welfare and heritage turkey farms

In 2014, Butterball announced that its turkeys had been American Humane Certified. But as animal welfare labels go, this is not a very meaningful one, indicating only minor improvements in conditions at best. If you truly care about animal welfare, a heritage bird is a better option. Some heritage turkey producers will also have certifications, such as Animal Welfare Approved, one of FoodPrint’s top picks, or Certified Humane. You can learn more about poultry labels in our Food Label Guide — and more about turkey production in our piece on the true cost of industrially raised turkeys.

Heritage turkey cost

When you buy a heritage turkey, you will pay more — especially when some supermarkets offer Butterballs for free at holiday times — but you will be supporting a small- to mid-sized producer. And in buying from a farm that’s committed to maintaining the legacy of old breeds, you yourself will be helping to preserve biodiversity in the food system. Think about adjusting for the added costs by serving less turkey per person and beefing up on sides. Everyone’s in it for the green bean casserole anyway.

Food Label Guide

How to find a heritage bird

A great place to start is your local farmers’ market (or farm, if you’re lucky enough to live near one). Specialty food stores will often sell heritage birds around the holidays — talk to a manager if you’re wondering whether they’ll be in stock. Independent or natural food stores — from small co-ops to Whole Foods — may have them as well. If none of these options are available to you, you can check out Heritage Foods USA, an excellent online retailer that sells birds raised by renowned breeder Frank Reese.

How to cook a heritage bird

Heritage birds are quite different from mass-produced supermarket turkeys, and require different cooking techniques as well: Brining and cooking “slow and low” will keep the bird from drying out. For tips on how to cook heritage turkeys to maximum deliciousness, watch this YouTube video featuring the Fabulous Beekman Boys.

Top photo by kolesnikovserg /Adobe Stock.

More Reading

Waste not, want not with “Ferment,” a new cookbook by Kenji Morimoto

October 1, 2025

For these cocoa farmers, sustainability and the price of beans are linked

September 17, 2025

You haven’t had wasabi until you’ve had it fresh — and local

September 11, 2025

How to make your kids’ school lunch more eco-friendly

August 19, 2025

No-cook meals: 40+ ways to enjoy peak summer produce without turning on your stove

August 12, 2025

Looking to jar up the season? Try a canning club

August 7, 2025

15+ ideas for delicious meatless grilling

July 1, 2025

4 Tips for Stretching Your Food Dollars

April 16, 2025

How to use extra onions

April 9, 2025

Our latest podcast episode on pistachios: The making of a food trend

April 1, 2025